When deciding between a Tensile Shed Vs Traditional Steel Shed, choosing the right outdoor covering structure for your property in Pakistan is a critical decision. Both options offer shade and weather protection, but they differ significantly in aesthetics, material durability, structural load, and overall installation cost.
Both can do a decent job at keeping off sunlight and rain, but the two structures have a different appearance, use different materials and have other differences as well.
Depending on what you need the structure for (housing, commercial purpose, school, restaurant, factory, etc.), the available space, the desired look and other factors, you have a few considerations to make before getting started on the project.
Here, we take a look at tensile sheds and traditional steel sheds to determine which might be a better choice for your property in Pakistan.
Tensile Shed Vs Traditional Steel Shed Options
A tensile shed typically consists of a structural framework with a specialized tensile fabric roof membrane.
The membrane is usually bonded to the framework in a way that puts the membrane under tension, giving the structure its signature look.
Tensile structures are extremely versatile in the sense that they can be shaped to fit most any space, configuration or design code.
These structures can be used for
• car parking,
• entrances,
• walkways,
• swimming pools,
• commercial areas,
• schools and colleges,
• industrial areas
and
• residential purposes
, among others.
What Is A Traditional Steel Shed?
A steel shed typically consists of a steel framework and a rigid roof covering.
The roof covering can be made from a variety of materials depending on the design and purpose of the structure.
Steel sheds are primarily seen for warehousing and industrial purposes, but can be used for other applications as well.
Although functional, steel sheds tend to look rather utilitarian compared to tensile structures.
Tensile Shed Vs Steel Shed: What Are The Differences?
The primary difference between the two structures lies in the nature of the roofing system.
While a steel building typically consists of a rigid roof design, a tensile structure usually has an open feel due to the nature of the roofing membrane.
1. Appearance
Modern tensile structures typically borrow from modern architecture in that they give the structure an arched or flowing appearance.
The roofline can be shaped to fit the design and space requirements of almost any site or building.
This gives the property an upscale look that steel structures typically cannot replicate.
For the purposes of a car parking area, factory or warehouse, this might not be an issue, but for a home, hotel, restaurant or other commercial building, a steel building can look rather industrial.
2. Design Flexibility
Thanks to the nature of the roof membrane, tensile structures are extremely flexible in terms of design and construction.
The roof can be shaped to meet most any set of design requirements.
This includes conforming around columns, walls and other structures.
This is ideal for situations where the area to be covered is not a simple rectangle or square.
While steel buildings can also be constructed with some flexibility in mind, this typically involves going against typical steel building construction methods and materials.
3. Natural Light
One of the benefits of a tensile roof structure is the amount of natural light it allows into the covered area.
The amount of light admitted will depend on the type of membrane used as well as its thickness.
A conventional steel building typically lets in very little light.
Depending on your needs, one structure might be preferable over the other based on this consideration.
In terms of creating a shaded area with plenty of open space on the sides, a tensile structure canopy would be ideal.
While a steel structure can also provide shade and shelter, its ability to let in natural light is greatly diminished.
4. Weight And “Look”
A large, open tensile structure can span huge distances without having the overwhelming visual presence that steel buildings tend to have.
Steel buildings have a certain rugged look to them that some people find distasteful, especially when it comes to residential construction.
5. Open-Air Feel
A well designed tensile shelter can provide shade while allowing the sides to remain open.
This makes it ideal for use as a car parking shelter or other similar applications.
A steel building can also provide an open-air feel but is limited in this regard by the roof design.
Which Is Better For A Car Parking Area?
For an open-air parking area, a tensile shelter would be the way to go provided that the design requirements call for an open-air feel.
Such a structure can be constructed to cover individual parking spaces or a large multi-car parking area as well.
A steel building might be better suited for a more enclosed parking garage or parking area that requires a more rigid roof design.
Which Is Better For A Warehouse?
For warehouse and industrial building structures, steel buildings become much more preferable due to the rigid nature of the roof and walls.
While a tensile building could be constructed to provide some open-air coverage for a loading dock or parking area, a traditional steel building might be better suited to the rigors of the warehouse itself.
Which Is Better For A Restaurant Or Commercial Property?
When it comes to structures for commercial properties or restaurants, the appearance of the finished structure becomes an important consideration.
A tensile shelter is ideal for providing an outdoor covering without the utilitarian appearance of a steel building.
Tensile structures can also be used for other purposes such as restaurants canopies, entrances, parking areas and much more.
Again, the finished appearance of the structure should be considered when factoring in this choice.
Is A Tensile Shed More Expensive Than A Steel Shed?
Actually, it’s difficult to say.
The actual cost of the project depends on a number of different variables pertaining to the needs of the end-user.
So, when comparing the two options, it’s best not to compare the cost per square foot.
For example, two structures of the same square footage can be vastly different in terms of design and materials used.
That said, when taking into account the total scope of work and materials, it’s easy to pick out which option would be less expensive.
As far as the structural materials go, the choice is fairly simple in that the steel building will require steel whereas a tensile structure will require a membrane.
A good way of looking at it is to compare the costs as far as labor and materials go.
What To Consider Before You Choose
When choosing between a tensile shelter and a steel building you should consider a few things.
What Is The Purpose?
Are you looking to build a simple parking canopy or does the building need to be enclosed?
Are you building a parking area, warehouse, shop, restaurant or something else entirely?
Each application has different structural and aesthetic requirements.
How Much Area Needs To Be Covered?
The dimensions and appearance of the area need to be taken into consideration when determining which building type is more suitable for the job.
Does Appearance Matter?
If the end-result is going to be highly visible or is part of a larger commercial structure, the overall aesthetics of the building may be important.
Do You Need An Open Or Enclosed Space?
Tensile structures are ideal for situations where you need protection from sunlight above but still want an open feel on the sides.
What Are The Site Conditions Like?
Prior to any construction work being done, the area where the building is going to be located should be assessed with regards to structural requirements, location, access, etc.
A wall mounted structure is going to have a lot more requirements than a free-standing canopy, for example.
A large commercial building is going to have much different requirements than a small residential canopy.
A proper site assessment goes a long way in eliminating potential problems further down the line.
Can A Tensile Structure Replace Every Steel Shed?
No.
While tensile structures can replace a lot of steel buildings, there are some situations where a conventional steel building is more appropriate.
If you need an enclosed area with rigid walls and a solid roof, a conventional building might be more appropriate.
Tensile structures, on the other hand, are great for canopies, shading and aesthetic structures where an open feel is preferred.
So, the choice really depends on the needs of the end-user.
Final Thoughts
When choosing between a tensile structure and a steel building, there are a number of different considerations to take into account.
For an open space where an arched appearance is desired, a tensile shelter would be the way to go.
For an enclosed structure such as a warehouse, a steel building might be more appropriate.
A number of other variables will also come into play such as the appearance of the end structure and the overall cost of the project.
When selecting the type of structure to build, the needs of the end-user should always be the driving force behind the project.
Frequently Asked Questions
What Is The Main Difference Between A Tensile Shed And A Steel Shed?
While a tensile shed uses a membrane for the roof, a steel shed uses a more rigid roof design.
Are Tensile Sheds Suitable For Residential Purposes?
Yes. Tensile structures can be used for residential purposes such as car parking, entrances and other outdoor structures.
Can Tensile Sheds Be Used For Commercial Purposes?
Yes. Tensile sheds can also be used for commercial purposes such as restaurants, hotels, entrances, walkways, shopping areas and much more.
Are Traditional Steel Sheds Better For Factories?
For enclosed factories and warehouses, a conventional steel building might be more appropriate. Tensile structures can still be used for other outdoor structures at the factory such as a loading dock or parking area.
How Long Does A Tensile Shed Last?
The lifespan of a tensile structure will depend on the membrane used, structural design, environmental exposure and a number of other things. A good material selection is necessary for a long lasting structure.
How Can I Get A Quote For A Tensile Shed In Pakistan?
Please get in touch with us by providing the approximate length and width, location, intended use and pictures of the site so that we can provide you with a quote.
Get A Tensile Shed Designed For Your Property Now
Imperial Tensiles specializes in designing and constructing custom tensile structures and shed solutions in Pakistan.
Whether you need a residential parking canopy, commercial coverage structure, walkway cover or any other customized tensile solution, the solution should be designed around your needs and site specifications.
At Imperial Tensiles, we offer a wide variety of tensile products and solutions to suit a range of needs.
Visit our website to learn more about the solutions we offer and how we can help you with your next project.
Suggested internal links:
• Tensile Structures
• Car Parking Sheds
• Commercial Canopies
• Retractable Shades
• Contact / Get a Quote












